Off-the-shelf machines also come as preconfigured packages that make it tougher to get exactly what you want. The a la carte approach is far more flexible, and you only pay for what you need. Order your machine. It's what the pros do.
Buying a new machine and ordering in on a custom basis can avoid a great deal of troubleshooting. LAPTOP VERSUS DESKTOP
While this issue can be a big one on land, that is usually not the case onboard a boat. You almost certainly want a laptop.
Laptops are a bit more expensive than desktops, but they are competitive in terms of features and they have become the industry standard when it comes to onboard machines. The ability to go portable and use the machine anywhere trumps almost any argument against it. With the right battery and some attention to charging, a laptop will allow you to do navigation work in the saloon, stateroom or at multiple helm stations. You can also take it home to plan your voyages, or use it aboard a charter or a friend's boat.
Laptops can be difficult to mount, leaving most boaters to simply use them on the nearest flat surface. But there are solutions for those who insist on a hard installation. Companies like RAM Mounting Systems make special hardware designed to hold a laptop in place at the helm (see link). Laptops also have ports to add an external screen and mouse, which can be mounted at the helm while the computer sits out of the way.
Of course, there are some boaters who may benefit from desktop machines, particularly those with large vessels who have opted for expensive PC-based navigation electronics.
Desktop machines do offer more flexibility to work on the computer, adding upgrades or fixing broken parts. While most laptops are closed systems, with components packed tight in the factory to achieve portability, desktop machines are designed to be manipulated by their owners. Manufacturers assume the user will "crack the case" in order to add a graphics card, a modem or some other component. The result is that desktop machines have wiring and expansion bays to accommodate additional drives and other upgrades – and room to work within the machine – that can be extremely helpful in some applications.
But for most boaters who want to connect a computer to a GPS and a few other instruments, then plan trips and navigate using standard electronic charting software, a laptop is the best solution.
MAC VERSUS PC
There are entire tomes to be read about the advantages and disadvantages of owning an Apple versus a PC and this debate is apt to continue long into the future. What is important to remember when buying an onboard computer is that everything that is true on land is also true at sea.
A Mac is an elegant, easy-to-use machine that is generally more stable than Windows-based machines and has little trouble with computer viruses (the bad guys don't write viruses to attack the Mac's operating system).
It also has a smaller support network and far fewer software offerings to choose from. For example, if you own a Mac, there are only two major navigation software packages available: NavimaQ and MacENC. If you own a PC, there are perhaps a dozen. Similarly, you can get a PC fixed almost anyplace you go, but finding an Apple store may be more difficult.
If you are weighing this decision, you might let familiarity be your guide. If you are already a Mac person, then taking a Mac onboard probably makes sense. It's a great piece of gear and you'll spare yourself the learning curve. Similarly, if you are a PC person, you may want to stick with the PC. Even if you have an interest in switching platforms, your boat is probably not the place to do so.
If you use both and you are in a quandary, go with the PC. You'll have more options, more support and you'll be in line with what most boaters are using.
BRAND NAMES
Let's assume, for the time being, that you are now in the market for a new laptop, a PC that you will be buying on a custom basis.
One of the first questions you will confront is whether to buy a marinized computer. Companies such as Marine Computer Systems, Argonaut, AR Engineering and Group Mobile offer machines that are built for marine use. Desktop models offer soldered wiring and watertight connections in a very small unit. Laptops have ruggedized casings that are designed to absorb shock. This is all good stuff – if you can afford it. The truth is that a marinized or hardened laptop can cost thousands of dollars more than a normal machine, and many electronics experts say they are simply not worth the expense.




























I have used my IBM Thinkpad R40 on board but find that the screen is unreadable in most sunlight situations. I see that some of the marine computers offer day light readable screens. Do any of the mainstream manufacturers (non-marine) offer daylight readable screens? What spec determines this? In other words, how can I tell if a screen will be readable from the specs?
Thanks very much. Interesting series.Â
Ed Waterman
Hi Glen,
Good story - focus is on the right things.
Let me add a couple words about the Mac: I currently use a new Mac Book on the boat and run Nobeltec VNS. As you know, the new Macs are  dual-boot machines - they can use both OS X and Windows. I prefer to boot the machine in one or the other, not the both-at-once option. It works great using XP Pro and all the interfaces work, including a SeaCom 4 to 1 serial to USB adapter box. I can also send routes to the Raymarine E chart plotter. As per your recommendation above, I only use the nav application on the Windows side - no email, no Word, etc. As the Mac is superior for those functions, I do all that on the OS X side (and am better protected for internet use).
The software reviews are very useful - especially your focus on the charts. Keep up the good work. HNickÂ
I do own and use on board of  my BI-40  Macbooc Pro Dual Core, 2.33MGHz. Using Boot Camp I have a choice to use OSX Leopard or Windows XP.
My navigation software NavSim SailCruiser (www.navsim.com) works flawlesly in WindowsXP.
Having new Mac I have it all and I am not limited just to Windows....Â
The single biggest issue with choosing a computer aboard a boat is a sunlight readable screen. There is a brightness measurement called "nits" which is supposed to be a measure of one screens measure of brightness to another. However, this indicator is often not published for many laptops. The ruggedized laptops like Panasonic Toughbooks (there are others), are made for outside field use and would be better suited to boating. Dell has a new PC that is supposedly sunlight readable and may publish the nits value. I have an HP Pavillion laptop which is unreadable in any sun. In my opinion, most PC's today have far more capability that anyone would need for normal boat use assuming it has a few usb ports for peripherals. To me, it is the screen readability that is the biggest concern. If you decide to use it as your only electronics unit (in addition to paper chart backup, always) make sure it is secured in place or it will "hit the deck" at the worst time!